Culture Vulture: 2023 YEAR IN REVIEW

December 22, 2023

YEAR IN REVIEW

Top 10 Theater

  1. The Beautiful Lady – Anne Bogart’s triumphant staging at La Mama brought Elizabeth Swados and Paul Schmidt’s 1984 cabaret musical about the Russian revolutionary poets to fiery life with across-the-board fine performances.

 S T A R R Busby in The Beautiful Lady

2. Stereophonic – David Adjmi’s play meticulously reproduced the creativity and tension of life in a recording studio, focusing on a Fleetwood Mac-like band, with an excellent cast who play and sing songs by Will Butler (of Arcade Fire) beautifully directed by Daniel Aukin on David Zinn’s astonishing set. 

Eli Gelb and Andrew R. Butler and the cast of Stereophonic

3. Buena Vista Social Club – This thrilling new musical at Atlantic Theater Company, developed and directed by Saheem Ali, wove together the histories of five Cuban musicians featured on the 1996 album (and the Wim Wenders documentary). The hot band, excellent singers, and exciting dancers combined to blast the audience with joy.

4. Infinite Life – Annie Baker’s characteristically spare and profound play about pain, time, and health used six superb actors masterfully directed by James Macdonald to cast a spell at Atlantic Theatre Company.

Kristine Nielsen, Brenda Pressley, Christina Kirk, Marylouise Burke, and Mia Katigbak in Infinite Life

5. Jaja’s African Hair Braiding – playwright Jocelyn Bioh knows her characters (the staff and clientele of a Harlem hair salon) and director Whitney White knows her audience – together with an exciting and hilarious cast, they blew the roof off of the Samuel Friedman Theatre on another dazzling David Zinn set.

Lakisha May (in chair) and Nana Mensah in JaJa’s African Hair Braiding

6. Sad Boys in Harpyland — Alexandra Tatarsky’s demonic cabaret/existential clownshow transformed the tiny upstairs space at Playwrights Horizons into a hilarious, theatrical, and dangerous hellscape, abetted by sound generator Shane Riley and director Irish McCloughan.

7. True West – I’ve seen many stagings of Sam Shepard’s famous play but this one stood out for its innovative all-Asian cast directed by Mei Ann Teo at People’s Light in Pennsylvania.

8. Days of Wine and Roses – Brian d’Arcy James and Kelli O’Hara dived deep into this intense chamber opera about a couple’s descent into alcoholism by Adam Guettel and Craig Lucas, directed by Michael Greif at Atlantic Theater Company.

9. Helen. – Violeta Picayo’s production at La Mama of Caitlin George’s play for En Garde Arts rang many surprising twists on familiar figures from Greek mythology.

10. (tie) Ecosex and the City – Annie Sprinkle and Beth Stephens created a luscious three-day festival of panels, films, and live shenanigans at Performance Space New York “exploring the earth as lover.”

Bob Dylan’s Philosophy of Modern Song – always-inventive filmmaker Michael Almereyda staged this one-night-only tribute to Dylan’s quirky survey of 20th century pop led by the great Meshell Ndegeocello and her band with the legendary André De Shields as magisterial master of ceremonies.

Best Music: boygenius, The Record; Romy, Midair; Everything but the Girl, Fuse; the National, First Two Pages of Frankenstein; Fred again… Tiny Desk Concert

Best TV: The Bear (great cast of rising stars – Jeremy Alan White, Ayo Edebiri, Ebon Moss-Bachrach, Liza Colon-Zayas – and phenomenal guest stars like Jamie Lee Curtis, below), Somebody Somewhere, Reservation Dogs.

Best Films: I didn’t see a lot of blockbusters. Barbie, of course, and Oppenheimer, but neither of them blew me away as much as the wildly underrated Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse. I admired documentaries galore: The Disappearance of Shere Hite, All the Beauty and the Bloodshed, Navalny, Leaning into the Wind – Andy Goldsworthy, 32 Sounds.But my movie-watching this year largely revolved around my MUBI subscription, which got me to see tons of quirky vintage foreign films (the 1980 Hungarian animated feature Bubble Bath, below) and fascinating indie gems I otherwise would have missed, many of them international films directed by women. Some favorites: Rotting in the Sun, Kokomo City, The Five Devils, The Sweet East, Ava, Fremont, Amanda, Joyland, Tori and Lokita.


Culture Vulture/Photo Diary: CEILI, BUENA VISTA SOCIAL CLUB, RESERVATION DOGS, THE BOY AND THE HERON, and more

December 19, 2023

Culture Vulture had a rich international weekend of activity.

Friday night I returned to the Irish Arts Center, where I saw a wonderful evening of Irish poetry just two weeks ago. The occasion for this visit was to see Céilí, a fascinating collaboration between Darrah Carr Dance, a company of fresh-faced youngsters devoted to invigorating Irish dance traditions, and Seán Curran Company, a funkier crew whose leader came up through the Bill T. Zones/Arnie Zane Company’s brand of innovative modern dance. The title of the show refers to a house party, and the evening did have a light-hearted, celebratory feel as various combinations of dancers took turns doing their party pieces. They mostly danced to sublime live accompaniment by fiddle-guitar duo Dana Lyn and Kyle Sanna, except for one virtuosic handclap-and-foot-stomp duet (“Box Tops”) by Trent Kowalik and Lauren Kravitz – all the more impressive because at this performance Kowalik went on as understudy for Benjamin Freedman; Evan Copeland covered Freedman’s other duties that night. Throughout the evening I couldn’t take my eyes off Kowalik and Copeland. Kowalik, one of the three kids who won the Tony Award sharing the title role in Billy Elliot: The Musical on Broadway, is tall and light-footed and seemingly effortlessly maintains the signature verticality of Irish dancing. Handsome bearded Copeland, a longtime Curran associate, stood out for the precision of the lyrical shapes his dancing created. It was a dense, continuous hour-long expression of joy.

A community jam session was taking place in the lobby as we left to go around the corner to Ardesia Wine Bar for a delicious dinner of small plates – portobello fries, tacos, charcuterie – and a bottle of Spanish mencia.

Saturday afternoon – More joy burst from the stage of the Atlantic Theater Company’s Linda Gross Theater from the first notes of Buena Vista Social Club, the thrilling new musical built around the legendary Cuban musicians who appeared on the 1996 album (put together by record executive Nick Gold, guitarist Ry Cooder, and musical director Juan de Marcos González) and in Wim Wenders’ 1998 documentary. For the stage production, developed and directed by Saheem Ali, playwright Marco Ramirez crafted a narrative to weave together the histories of five key musicians and their lives in Havana in 1956 (pre-Castro) and 1996. He may have borrowed a page from Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom to portray Omara Portuondo as a demanding diva around whose whims the recording sessions take place. But Ali has assembled an incredibly talented cast – Natalie Venetta Belcon as Omara, Kenya Browne as her younger self, Renesito Avich as Eliades Ochoa, Julio Monge as Compay Segundo, Mel Seme as Ibrahim Ferrer, Jainardo Batista Sterling as Rubén Gonzalez, and Jared Machado, Olly Sholotan, and Leonardo Reyna as the younger Compay, Ibrahim, and Rubén – and he and music director Marco Pagula put together a spectacular band.

As if the music blasting from the stage wasn’t deliriously exciting enough, Patricia Delgado and Justin Peck fill the stage with energetic sexy choreography for six terrific dancers. Anulfo Maldonado’s nimble sets, Dede Ayite’s dazzling period costumes, and Tyler Micoleau’s bold lighting all contribute to the visual excitement. For anyone familiar with the album and the film, layers of feeling can’t help piling on top of each other watching these extraordinary singers and musicians exude love and devotion for Cuban music. I can’t imagine this show won’t move to Broadway, where I hope to revisit it, but I don’t think I’ll ever forget the joy of sitting in the third row of an intimate Off-Broadway theater receiving the blessing of this gorgeous show.

Our friend Sari and her adolescent son Sam met us afterwards for a stroll through the Whitney Museum, whose current offerings introduce museumgoers to Japanese-American artist Ruth Asawa (I first learned about her from the postage stamp in her honor; see “Untitled” above), African-American painter Henry Taylor, and in the project room Indigenous sculptor Natalie Ball. I never know what’s going to catch my eye at the Whitney.

I felt indifferent to most of Taylor’s unbeautiful paintings, though I thought his room of portraits of artists was witty (Tyler the Creator on a suitcase, above; Deena Lawson “in the Lionel Hamptons,” below) and his installation dedicated to the uniforms of the Black Panthers arresting.

A complicated exhibition called “Inheritance,” curated by Rujeko Hockley, riffs on lineage and artistic legacies. Andrea Carlson’s ambitious Red Exit weaves evocative native symbols with abstract images.

Wakeah Jhane’s Grandmother’s Prayers goes there with one resonant image.

And I found multiple ways to appreciate Sturtevant’s homage to Felix Gonzalez-Torres’s 1991 installation “Untitled (Blue Placebo),” in which viewers are invited to take a piece of blue-wrapped candy from a large rectangular field of them.

That tasty caramel tided me over until we had dinner at Osteria Nonnino on Horatio Street – paccheri with the spicy house sausage-and-vodka sauce and a bottle of nero d’avola.

Home from our expedition, Andy and I finished watching season 1 of Reservation Dogs on Hulu, one of the weirdest TV series in an era of extremely weird TV series. RezDogs mashes up Schitt’s Creek with Somebody Somewhere but in a blandly suburban Native community in Oklahoma. Taika Waititi co-created the series with Sterlin Harjo, and it has all the eccentricity and casual/jokey supernatural eruptions familiar from Waititi’s other work (Thor: Ragnarok, Jojo Rabbit, What We Do In The Shadows). The all-native cast is full of wonderful actors I’ve never seen before, some of them very young (see above), all of them masters at deadpan comedy. I usually give myself permission to enjoy the luxury of subtitles because dialogue flies by so quickly, but with this show it’s especially fascinating to read the native words that show up as regularly as the affectionate sobriquet “shitass”; also fascinating to see that the screenplay spells “Indian” as “NDN.”

A weird thing happened just as we were turning in for the night. A couple of drunken guys got into an altercation on the street in front of my building, and the one getting beat up pressed all the buzzers until someone buzzed them in, at which point they proceeded to tromp up and down the stairs yelling and fighting. “Ehh, macho straight guys, let them settle it amongst themselves,” I thought. But then I heard a woman scream, so I called 911. The scuffling and yelling went on, someone spat on someone, which escalated the fighting. Eventually the friends of the fighters dragged them away. Shortly thereafter four wet-behind-the-ears NYPD officers showed up, looking scared and clueless. The fighters had apparently grabbed two fire extinguishers and sprayed each other with them, so a cloud hung over the hallway. Saturday night in the big city.

Sunday afternoon we trekked down to the East Village to see The Boy and the Heron, Hayao Miyazaki’s valedictory film, a beautiful and trippy fantastic-voyage mythological yarn full of tiny references to characters and images from the Studio Ghibli pantheon. We came home and I made two fairly ambitious dishes from the New York Times Cooking app – a kale and squash salad with almond-butter vinaigrette (per Ali Slagle) and spicy roasted mushrooms with polenta (thank you, Yotam Ottolenghi!).

Reading the Sunday New York Times fed my soul with a couple of items. The Sports section on Sunday featured a full-page article about football star Jordan Poyer headlined “A Safety Finds Enlightenment In Ayahuasca.” Dan Pompei compiled a respectful and factually accurate summation of plant medicine as Poyer talked openly and vulnerably about how the medicine helped him bring his alcohol abuse under control. Also, in the Times Magazine “Talk” column, David Marchese interviews David Byrne, who speaks thoughtfully and personally about change. While discussing the Buddhist concept of no-fixed-self and how what we think about ourselves can change, Byrne is asked how he himself has changed.

“Wow. Well, I realized quite a few years ago that as much as I might like to deny it, I harbored a lot of racial biases. At that point, a younger liberal person would say, Oh, I’m not racist, or I believe in equality. But at the same time, I was aware that I was also harboring these inner biases that I could occasionally sense. I realized I may rationally say that I’m not racist, but I have implicit biases that I would like to deny but they’re there. Overcoming those is more difficult than just rationally saying, Oh, no, that’s not right. Those beliefs and biases, whether they’re about race or women’s rights or whatever they might be, those things can take a long time to fundamentally change within us. I would like to think that I’ve been engaged in that process and was trying in [his Broadway show] American Utopia.”

Marchese asks, How do you do it?Good question. Let me think of some examples. People might say, Germans don’t have a sense of humor, or all Italians are really passionate; you might see a bunch of kids on a street corner and think, There’s trouble, I’m going to avoid them. In my experience, the way to work through some of that stuff is just to get to know other people as individuals a little bit better, and that starts to break those biases down. But that’s a slow process. And for somebody who’s not maybe the most social person in the world, that takes some work.”

I so appreciate David Byrne’s honest introspection. He sat in front of us when we saw David Adjmi’s superb play Stereophonic at Playwrights Horizons (he later wrote an essay about the play for the PH website), and I watched him chat freely with the fans around him, which I’ve hardly ever seen celebrities do in public. So I feel like I got to witness him stepping out of his comfort zone and practicing “getting to know other people as individuals.”

I’ve been thinking about how so much of the divisiveness in the world these days seems to boil down to people’s tolerance level for behaviors, identities, and beliefs that are different from their own. How much of that is learned, how much is inherent, how much is malleable? I feel like I have not only a huge tolerance but a deep and abiding appetite for experiencing difference. Was I born that way? Some of it surely has to do with realizing I was gay at an early age and looking at the world through a queer lens. I like the way another Times Magazine contributor, Venita Blackburn, put it, writing about the animated Japanese series Sailor Moon: “queerness is not just sexual…queerness is also existing under duress, where one’s instinct toward self-determination is a kind of spiritual expanse that grows from deep within the body and psyche then cascades out into an eventual shape unlike most others.”

But the other circumstantial piece that overwhelmingly influenced my experience of difference was growing up as a military dependent. My father grew up as a poor, uneducated farm kid in culturally homogeneous small towns in the Midwest. He didn’t lay eyes on a black person until he was 12, by which point he’d been indoctrinated with all the racist stereotypes of midcentury American culture. Ironically, his joining the U. S. Air Force and raising four kids meant that we got to travel all over the country and to Japan, which automatically exposed us to people, food, landscapes, and attitudes unlike our own.

Lucky me to have had that upbringing, and lucky me to have landed in New York City, where my craving for exposure to difference and other cultures can never be exhausted.


Quote of the day: Vaclav Havel on goodwill

November 25, 2023

GOODWILL

I feel that the dormant goodwill in people needs to be stirred. People need to hear that it makes sense to behave decently or to help others, to place common interests above their own, to respect the elementary rules of human coexistence. They want to be told about this publicly…Goodwill longs to be recognized and cultivated. For it to develop and have an impact it must hear that the world does not ridicule it…people want to hear that decency and courage make sense, that something must be risked in the struggle against dirty tricks. They want to know that they are not alone, forgotten, written off.

–Vaclav Havel, Summer Meditations


Events: DADDY LOVER GOD update

November 9, 2023

It’s a busy week in the world of Daddy Lover God: a sacred intimate journey !

Not long after reading at a sports bar on the Upper West Side to a mostly straight (though attentive) audience, I had the pleasure of appearing as a guest for a joint meeting of two gay male nudist groups in Washington, D.C., NoCover and Buddies23. My friend Frederic, who’s a member of both groups, cooked up the idea of this salon as a way for the two groups to collaborate, and he and his two handsome roommates (Stephen and Mateo) hosted the event, which was a lot of fun. Let it be known that I am open to being invited to visit other gay male nudist groups.

I also had the honor of returning to the Body Electric School’s “Erotic Liberation Podcast” for my second appearance. Host Craig Cullinane is a dear friend and an excellent Body Electric instructor, and his interviewing skills are stellar. Questioning me about the book, my practice, and the concept of sacred intimacy, he elicited from me about as much eloquence and clarity as I have ever been able to muster. I’m quite proud of this interview. Check it out here and let me know what you think.

This Saturday afternoon, November 11 at 4pm, I will be doing an event at MMX (Male Massage Exchange) in New York City, reading from Daddy Lover God and facilitating a conversation about sacred intimacy and sexual healing work. MMX is a very cool membership organization (membership is free) that serves primarily as a massage studio, offering classes, play parties, and professional treatments. I have taught classes there, the Body Electric School has run workshops in the space, and the NYC community of Sacred Brothers organizes monthly gatherings there. This event is intended to expand MMX’s offerings in the direction of community socializing — the salon idea, not unlike the meeting in Washington, DC. Admission is free, but you’ll want to register here. MMX will provide snacks and a pay-by-donation bar, and I will have copies of the book available for purchase and signing. Come through and say hello!


Culture Vulture: HELEN., SABBATH’S THEATER, and STEREOPHONIC

October 31, 2023

Cultural weekend! Friday night, Andy and I met friends for dinner at The Smith in the East Village in honor of a recently departed college chum. It was Hallo-weekend and the streets were full of costumed revelers. We were most amused to see a couple dressed as tourist (him in I ❤️ NY t-shirt) and the Statue of Liberty.

Saturday – beautiful day, up to 80 degrees. We took part in the Gays Against Guns action in response to the mass shootings in Lewiston, ME. I had a Google Hangout conversation with Alastair Curtis, a young theater artist in London who’s just discovered the work of Harry Kondoleon and wanted to talk to me in preparation for a reading he’s doing of Christmas on Mars. In the evening, Andy and I were back in the East Village to see Helen., the SuperGeographics production of Caitlin George’s play directed by Violeta Picayo. In the lobby we chatted a little with producer Anne Hamburger (whose En Garde Arts brought the show to La Mama), Linda Chapman, Chay Yew (looking very buff), and two young artists Anne is cultivating. I enjoyed the play, a dense, poetic, cheeky, queer/feminist riff on Greek mythology that reminded me of Young Jean Lee’s Lear the way it played fast and loose with familiar stories. In this version, Helen and her twin sister (!) Klaitemnestra and their sibling Timandra operate under the supervision of Elis, god of discord. This restless Helen isn’t waiting around to be abducted from her husband – she’s got wanderlust and knows how to use it. Picayo’s excellent production – light, fun, funny – made extensive use of quirky props (crowns, marbles, a barbecue) and almost continuous underscoring (by the great sound designer Darron L. West) with terrific performances, especially by charismatic Constance Strickland as Eris and Lanxing Fu as Helen (below center, with Grace Bernardo as Klaitemnestra and Melissa Coleman-Reed as Timandra).

Sunday afternoon we saw Sabbath’s Theater, Philip Roth’s late novel adapted for the stage by John Turturro with Ariel Levy. I never read the novel but the promotional material and the advance feature in the New York Times built up my expectations for a sexier/ filthier event than the New Group production turned out to be. But I guess for some (straight?) people any reference to masturbation comes off as racy rather than (as Roth has always demonstrated) a typical feature of most people’s sex lives. For all its lustiness, the play is primarily a melancholy contemplation of loss, desire, and death as the title character Sabbath (played by the brave, inventively comic, ever-watchable Turturro, below), a former puppeteer brought down by arthritis and a sex-with-student scandal, recalls the lovers, friends, and relatives he’s lost and considers joining them by throwing himself out the window of his high-rise apartment or walking naked into the sea. Jason Kravits and the great Elizabeth Marvel have fun playing all the other characters with distinctly different costumes, voices, and body habitus. Jo Bonney’s production struck me as tame, and in contrast to Helen., the sound score (by Mikaal Sulaiman) came off as intrusive and annoying at times rather than evocative or scene-setting. I pointed out to Andy that the fine-print trigger warning in the program (“This production contains nudity, sexual situations, strong and graphic language, and discussion of suicide.”) could apply to virtually every show at the New Group.

photo by Jeenah Moon for the New York Times

I loved Rob Weinert-Kendt’s succinct summary: “If Robert Altman directed a Chekhov play about a 1970s rock band struggling to perfect their next album, it might look (and sound) something like David Adjmi’s STEREOPHONIC.” I saw the play a couple of weeks ago and it’s stuck with me like few plays I’ve seen in recent years. A three-hour play can seem a little daunting these days, but Daniel Aukin’s production at Playwrights Horizons casts a spell. When I try to name the unusually evocative atmosphere to myself, I keep coming back to Fassbinder – the intense attention to tiny increments of human behavior, the honesty about intertwined love and depravity, artists at work, extraordinary design on every level, occasional longeurs but that being part of the astonishing success of capturing life in its complexity. Pop music was my first love, and I related to the play’s deep immersion in rock music culture much the same as Todd London did in his terrific essay on the PH website. (There you can also read commentary by David Byrne, who happened to be in the audience for the performance I attended; my friends and I noted how remarkably friendly and chatty Byrne was with the people sitting around him. One member of my posse is a hardcore Fleetwood Mac nerd and regaled us at intermission and afterwards with all of his observations about the Easter eggs hidden throughout the play – for instance, that Lindsay Buckingham has a brother who’s an Olympic swimmer, like the LB character in the play. And he knew exactly which Steve Nicks song was deemed too long to be included on Rumours.) The set designed by David Zinn manages to look completely natural and lived-in while being actually insanely meticulous in its creation of an artificial environment that works as an additional character in the play. Ditto the impossibly intricate sound design by Ryan Rumery. The performers are uniformly excellent, all playing their own instruments on ingenious original songs by Will Butler of the Arcade Fire. But what impressed me most of all is how the playwright, the director, and Tom Pecinka, the actor who plays Peter (the Lindsay Buckingham stand-in), collaborated to create the most nuanced and compassionate portrait of a perfectionist I’ve seen in any medium.